As you may have heard, the BSA announced that moving forward, it will allow girls to fully participate and register in Cub Scout and Boy Scout programs, should local Scouting partners choose to recruit girls into their pack, depending on the needs of their youth.

The BSA Board of Directors unanimously decided to welcome girls into its Cub Scout program and to deliver a Scouting program for older girls that will enable them to advance and earn the highest rank of Eagle Scout as of 2019.

The BSA conducted extensive research, including two Harris surveys, as well as four research efforts that included input from nationwide family listening sessions. The results were overwhelmingly positive in support of the decision to welcome girls.

The question remains, however, how this inclusiveness will affect current Cub Scout packs and what options now exist for leaders, chartered organizations, and parents of eligible children.

The BSA explained, “When girls join Cub Scouting in fall 2018, (beginning at age five), packs may welcome them right away. An existing pack may choose to recruit girls or remain an all-boy pack. When creating a new pack, a chartered organization may form an all-boy pack, an all-girl pack or a pack of girls and boys.”  Each chartered organization will decide how or whether to implement these program changes and what activities will best serve their youth.

Cub Scout dens, however, will remain single-gender — all boys or all girls. Cub Scout packs can include any combination of all-boy or all-girl dens. The choice is left to individual pack leaders in cooperation with their chartered organization.

This hybrid model builds on the benefit of a single-gender program while also providing character and leadership opportunities for both boys and girls.

“I’ve seen nothing that develops leadership skills and discipline like this organization,” said Randall Stephenson, the association’s National Board Chairman. “It’s time we make these outstanding leadership development programs available to girls.”

Many big things won’t change, however. Uniforms, activities, rank advancement requirements and Youth Protection policies will remain the same.

Regarding Youth Protection, the policies match existing rules in place for the Venturing program for young men and young women. When a Scouting activity includes both boys and girls, there must be both male and female leaders present. At least one of those leaders must be registered as an adult member of the BSA, having passed a background check.

Existing program content and activities are appropriate for boys and girls alike. Education experts have evaluated program content and confirmed the relevance of the program for young women, despite some questions from the Girl Scouts.

Many have welcomed the announcement with open arms and shouts of praise for the consideration of their daughters, granddaughters, and neighbors to have the same opportunities and choices as boys.

Brian Wistisen, a third-generation Eagle Scout with two sons who have achieved the same honor says, “I was skeptical at first, thinking of the logistics of having young boys and girls together on camping trips and outings, thinking there may be benefits to the existing separation. But after further introspection and clarification on the new changes, I’m thrilled that my eleven-year-old daughter can earn an Eagle and have the same opportunities to learn leadership, preparedness, and self-reliance skills just like her brothers…should she desire.”

The current desire of the BSA is stated as follows: “To expand their programs to serve more young people in the United States.” After all, the values of the Scout Law – trustworthy, loyal, helpful, friendly, courteous, kind, obedient, cheerful, thrifty, brave, clean and reverent – are relevant and important values for young men and young women as we look to the future of this great nation.

For more information on individual Scouting programs, please visit:


  1. Avatar
    Joshua Protheroe- Eagle Scout, Vigil honor says:

    At first i was extremely skeptical. Having grown up in the program from tigers to eagle and with two sons in the program it upset me at first. HOWEVER, i thought back to the first national jamboree i attended a mere 18 years ago and remembering how meeting scouts from all over the world both boys and girls. Remembering the fun we all had it didnt matter what gender you were, the reality was quite simple: change is hard, get over it. If you dont like the program…. Too badbecause since 1910 the boy scouts has grown boys into men and now girls want to have the fun too! Rock on bsa

  2. Avatar
    Stuart Weisberg says:

    I’m a Cubmaster for a pack of 30 boys and 5 girls. We’re not talking about huge numbers here. The girls in the pack like to camp; the boys like to draw, generally. We haven’t had to change any programming. The boys did better with popcorn sales, except for my daughter who was tied for first. Overall, neither the boys nor girls seem to care the other is present.

  3. Avatar
    A Father says:

    I believe this will ruin the boy scouts. I think all of the activities will change to what most girls like and most boys will quit. If you want to see what that looks like, take a look at any public school, It is all about the girls. This is why most hate school and do poorly.

  4. Avatar
    Naomi Walker says:

    This is not taking anything from the Girl Scouts. Not every little girl wants to be a Girl Scout. I wanted to be a Boy Scout and had no interest in the Girl Scouts. I am glad my daughters will have the option.

  5. Avatar
    LouAnn Newton says:

    I am so saddened by the Boy Scouts of America trying to take over the girls where is their honor and support for the Girl Scouts of America? Why are they dishonoring the girls like this.

    1. Avatar
      Aimee Cantero says:

      They’re not dishonoring anyone; GSUSA isn’t right for all girls. I was one of those forced to be a Girl Scout because there wasn’t another option, and for girls like me it leaves a really bad taste in your mouth. One of my three girls already wants to be a Cub Scout and I am thrilled my girls have the CHOICE of which program they want to be involved in. Besides…MOST countries that have Scouting have been co-ed for DECADES. Test exceptions (until now) we’re the Middle East and the US. Girl Scouts isn’t losing ANYONE…girls who are likely to join Scouts didn’t want to be Girl Scouts in the first place.

      1. Avatar
        Julia Kitay says:

        I would have rather been a boy scout also! Beats doing arts and crafts and home economics all the time. That was my experience in girl scouts! The boy scout curriculum is so much better!

    2. Avatar
      Angela Beck says:

      They aren’t taking anything away from any group, and certainly not dishonoring girls. My daughter is a Girl Scout, and I am a Girl Scout Leader. I’m my area, the Boy Scouts has a lot more to offer kids, and I’m so happy I can be a part of those opportunities.

  6. Darryl Alder
    Darryl Alder says:

    I love Scouting and what it has done for my dad, my brothers, and my sons. I am happy that my granddaughters can get in on the fun, but sorry it skipped my own daughters

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

1 × 1 =

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.